PPQ – Peanut Butter-Banana Cream Pie with Hot Fudge Sauce
March 13, 2011 in pie

This week’s Project Pastry Queen recipe was chosen by Josie of Pink Parsley and she chose the amazingly delicious Peanut Butter-Banana Cream Pie with Hot Fudge Sauce. And great timing too since tomorrow is Pi Day!
I am late posting this because I’ve been procrastinating. See, it was quite the undertaking. Crust, custard, chocolate, peanut butter, hot fudge, whipped cream… it took me all day long! But it was so worth it! I think I inhaled that piece up there in less than 2 minutes.
A few notes:
I used White Chocolate Wonderful because why use plain peanut butter when you can use white chocolate peanut butter? Go buy it. Now. (You can find it at Walmart, Target, pretty much anywhere.)
The crust tasted slightly underbaked to me and I left it in for 5 extra minutes or so. Keep an eye on that one.
Do not put hot fudge sauce in a squeeze bottle. It will explode.
If you don’t do gelatin for whatever reason, I think the pie would be fine without it. It won’t cut perfectly but between cooking the eggs and the cornstarch, it should be a-okay. Just don’t forget to add the banana liqueur!
So happy early Pi Day and make sure you check out Josie’s post for the recipe!






Welcome back to PPQ! Glad you liked the pie – it was definitely a lot of work, but so worth it!
Oooooh, this looks SO yummy! Wow – great pie!
Great looking pie and great photos! How could that dessert be bad?!
wow that looks awesome and i love PB, bananas, and hot fudge :)
lovely picture, too! great photography!
This looks just divine!! Banana, peanut butter, and chocolate …. YUM
Seriously looks amazing. I think I could bathe in that. TMI? Anyway…I’m looking for the flip phone… ♥- Katrina
I love the look of this pie! I’ve never heard of white chocolate peanut butter. I’ll have to locate some because I adore white chocolate anything! Thanks for commenting on my blog. I’ve added yours to my Google Reader and look forward to reading your future posts.
This should totally be called Elvis pie :) Sounds like a fun pie to try sometime. I bet my hubs would love it.
This pie looks AMAZINGGGG! Oh my gosh I am drooling ;)
Can’t wait to try out the recipe!
Amanda, you have a beautiful blog and this is such a lovely pie. Just in time to celebrate Pi Day! Thanks for sharing your creation. Looking forward to seeing more from you! :)
that looks pretty awesome…