Baked Potato Salad

Page 2 of 2 | Previous page

18 comments on this post.
  1. Alicia @ AliGirl Cook:

    Potatoes, cheese, and bacon! How could you go wrong?!

  2. Pam @ From Apples To Zucchini:

    Yummy! I found a love for baked or roasted potatoes is potato salad not long ago myself – what a difference it makes! This looks delicious! I want some right now!

  3. Rachel @ Baked by Rachel:

    Yum! I’d have to leave out the sour cream or find a good substitute but the bacon, cheese and baked part of this has me hooked :)

  4. Julia:

    Wow, talk about the Law of Attraction! I was at a retirement party at a restaurant in Wednesday, and they served this. I thought it was AMAZING and was going to look for recipes. And here it came through my RSS feed today.

    I cannot wait to make this, it’s so good, and normally, I don’t like potato salad.

    Thanks!

  5. Erin:

    Mmm I bet this would be good served warm too!

  6. amanda:

    Totally! I bet it would taste like a twice-baked potato! Mmm!

  7. natalie (the sweets life):

    okay this is just awesome! bet this would go over huge at a summer BBQ!

  8. Lisa~~:

    At 1am I want this and I’m wondering how long it would take to whip this up. At least I know what I’ll be making soon.

    Lisa~~
    Cook Lisa Cook

  9. nicole:

    I’ve done this before. We threw small red potatoes on the grill and then cubed them and tossed a potato salad together that way. I agree sooo much better than boiled potatoes.

  10. Veronica:

    Oh, I agree with you 100% Down with regular, up with this one! It’s the only one I really like, but I will have to bake the potatoes next time. I didn’t think about it at the time, but it is just WRONG to boil the potatoes you’re using in a “baked” potato salad. LOL! Great photos.

  11. Katrina @ In Katrina's Kitchen:

    There are some red potatoes on my counter just asking to be made into this today. No they are begging I think. Seriously.

  12. Stefanie:

    I’m not a fan of potato salad, but this sort of potato salad I can do. I saw the title and the picture, and I was won over instantly! Great recipe!

  13. Keila @ Ridiculously Delicious:

    okay, i don’t make potato salad that often because my husband does not allow mayo in the house. lol. however, I love it and can’t wait to try this recipe to take to the next ‘get-together’. It looks amazing. Thanks for sharing!

  14. Tammy:

    This looks so good, Can I make it ahead of time, like the day before ?. we are having a party for my daughter, and would like to use this recipe instead of the usual potato salad.

  15. amanda:

    Yeah, I think it would be fine if you made it the day before. I doubt the bacon would stay crisp overnight but I think it would be just as good. Or you could add the bacon the day of. :)

    Thanks for reading and commenting!

  16. Tammy:

    Thank you so much for replying, forgot about the bacon ;).

  17. Tiffney:

    Ive made a variation of this and have used the garden vegetable cream cheese in it instead of sour cream. Makes it very creamy and falvorful.

  18. Terry:

    Actually had a very similar salad in a corporate box at an Astro’s game last year. It is TO DIE FOR! I came home, and immediately got to work trying to re-create it!

Leave a comment