Cookie Dough Muffins Tops with Chocolate Streusel – Guest Post!
February 28, 2012 in cookie
Have I got a treat for you guys today!
A few night ago, I was having a whine whine whine moment on Twitter over the husband’s upcoming deployment and my dear friend Katrina offered to bake up something yummy for y’all. Sometimes I wonder if I would survive without my Twitter peeps.
If you aren’t already reading In Katrina’s Kitchen, you absolutely must! The girl is not only an amazingly creative baker, but she has a serious knack for finding fun foodie items. Without her, I would’ve never know that white chocolate syrup exists. And that would be a real shame.
—-
Hi there! I’m Katrina and I blog at In Katrina’s Kitchen. Amanda is busy being supermom and superwife this week so I’m taking over for a day. I hope you don’t mind. I brought muffins!

Well sorta. They’re muffin tops. Made with cookie dough. And topped with chocolate streusel. Did I mention that I like to make crazy things in my kitchen? That’s what my blog should be called…In Katrina’s Crazy Kitchen. Anyways, don’t hold it against Amanda that I hijacked her blog and put this in front of you. It started out inncocently enough (it always does). I saw a recipe for blueberry muffin tops and thought I would give them a whirl. However the recipe called for a tube of sugar cookie dough and I mistakenly picked up chocolate chip cookie dough- you can’t fault a girl on that. It all went downhill from there, especially when I decided to top it off with chocolate streusel. The streusel makes a mess and you could leave it off but why would you? These are like big, fluffy muffin top cookies that you can enjoy with your coffee anytime day or night.

adapted from Pillsbury
Ingredients
Instructions
- Let cookie dough stand at room temperature for about 10 minutes to soften. Heat oven to 350F and line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper.
- In a small bowl combine flour, baking soda, and baking powder; set aside.
- In the bowl of your mixer beat cookie dough and cream cheese until combined. Add egg, vanilla, and milk. Slowly add the dry ingredients that you had set aside. This will yield a thick batter.
- Drop batter by heaping Tablespoons (or use a large cookie scoop) 1 to 2 inches apart onto parchment-lined baking sheets.
- Sprinkle with streusel topping and bake 15 minutes until edges begin to brown. Cool on the baking sheet for 2 minutes before transferring to cooling racks. Yield: 12 large muffin tops
- Melt butter in a microwave-safe bowl. Add the dry ingredients on top.
- Incorporate the dry ingredients with your FINGERS until the mixture is moist and crumbly. If you stir it with a spoon it will congeal into a huge ball of goo.
Notes
Baking times will vary depending on how big your muffin tops are. If you are having difficulty judging if they are finished bake until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.






Fantastic guest post! LOVE these muffin tops! And yes, twitter friends really are the best sometimes!
They sound awesome! Do they have a muffin-like texture? Or are they more like soft cookies?
They are soft and have a little crumb to them- just like a muffin!
So sweet of you to help Amanda out. These look deeeelish!
Insane! Wow – not sure where to start. I know I want about 3 of them!
Oh HECK yes. The tops are the best part of the muffin anyway!! I’ll take these for breakfast any day. :)
Cookie dough streusel? Yum! Great idea.
This recipe sounds great! I have a question, after reading through the instructions, I noticed that Step 2 (In a small bowl combine flour, baking soda, and baking powder; set aside.) doesn’t get mentioned again…do you add those ingredients to the cookie dough & cream cheese for the batter? Thanks!
Oops :) Will get right on that… Thanks!
Can’t wait to try the recipe :)
These are awesome, so sweet, Katrina! I hope you are coping well Amanda!
I’m speechless! Wait, no I’m not… I WANT THESE NOW!!!
you had me at streusel. :) oh and the tops of muffins are the best part of a muffin. these look incredible, katrina!
ooo this so sounds delightful!!
Love these muffin tops – perfect guest post
Wow. These look absolutely amazing! I might have to make these this weekend!
These look insanely decadent – yum!!! I used to be completely addicted to store-bought cookie dough, I’m not sure it’s safe to bring it into my house again :)
Want to do this for tomorrow. Was wondering can I use my chocolate chip cookie recipe and add the other ingredients since I don’t have a tube of the cookie dough?
I don’t see why not. I would love to know how they turn out! :)
Those look amazing!!!! Can’t wait to try them!! But I have a question….it says to use store bought cookie dough. Would it work the same if I were to make my own cookie dough and use that instead of the store bought kind???
Thanks so much! <3
I don’t see why not. I would love to know how they turn out!
Awesome!!! I will definitely let you know how they turn out after I make them!!! :)
Katrina, These sound fantastic and look amazing! Can’t wait to try them!
These rock my world! Yum!
I made these this morning using my chocolate chip cookie recipe. I also put a whole package of cream cheese in it Then I doubled the flour baking powder and cocoa added it in. Then I doubled the streusel topping. Baked them for 12 minutes and they turned out wonderful. Everyone loved them. So thank you soooo much for this recipe.
Great to hear! Now you are making me hungry!! :)
These look so yum! It’s a muffin top, with cookie dough, AND a streusel. My boyfriend would say that there’s just too many Kobes on one team. And it’s true. We got some major allstars in this muffin top.
Such delicious looking they are. I will try the recipe today and let you know about my results.